At Filemobile, we manage the deployment of a number of UGC contests. People upload pictures, videos of things they like, explain themselves to a webcam or write a story in order to be considered for a prize. It's pretty straight forward until you have to pick a winner. You could go with a random draw, but that's no fun. A classic voting scheme keeps people coming back, it provides a sense of competition and it produces a winner.
Contest hosts want to maximize the number of times a person can vote. If you do not wish to have users log in to vote, they can vote repeatedly. Although this can translate into page views, more and more UIs are moving to a stationary experience, where pages are more dynamic and don't require page refreshes. In order to prevent people from just hacking away at it, or writing scripts to vote automatically, we always require a captcha.
There are a number of options for a voting process if you require the person to log in. Our system is able to attribute votes to a logged-in user and hence regulate the frequency of voting ie. voting once per day, once per entry, etc... Daily voting generates more engaging page views, as users return repeatedly to complete the experience (however short!).
The main problem with having people log in to vote, is that they have to register. Registration pages are notoriously bouncy: people hit them and split.
This is a good primer on bounce and exit rates.
Long site registration forms can be the touch of death, but there are ways to minimize the bounciness with shorter forms and potentially, services like Facebook Connect, Google Friend Connect, and other single sign-on systems.
A two-step process would make it easier for a person to engage the site and as a result, lower the bounce rate on that page. The first step is a fast and simple, one-click register experience. Once a person is logged in, he can vote and comment. They have a display name, an avatar, and all the fixins. You can see this happening on my blog using Facebook Connect.
If the person wishes to submit an entry to the contest, we need some more information. Another form is presented to them, asking for name, address, etc... At this point, we would not require a captcha.
In the case where a 3rd party identity isn't used, users must at least enter a password and confirm their email in order to participate.
Here are some ways people try to log fraudulent votes, and what to do about it:
1) A cheater can register repeatedly with phoney email addresses, and basically get unlimited votes. Without centralized identity, we can mitigate this by sending activation emails (yuk). The alternative is the contest host being prepared to manually search a vote log xls file and disqualify votes.
2) The cheater could write a script to break your captcha and vote like crazy, automatically. A good programmer can use a combination of OCR software and other methods to read and crack a captcha. A better captcha makes this possible for only the more rare wily hacker. At that point, we can usually detect a crazy number of vote requests coming in via IP address. The user is denied access, and we can determine an estimated number of fraudulent votes.
3) The best fail safe is to simply reserve the right, in the rules, to use discretion in selecting a winner. If some jerk does manage to cheat, turf him.
I think voting is fun and effective for UGC contests. If publishers and sponsors take the appropriate care, ensure a reasonable user experience, and allow discretion in the rules and regulations, voting can contribute greatly to the success of the project.
April 18, 2008 -- CTV's Canadian Idol 'Last Chance Auditions' took things further today by launching their first viral video wall ... allowing fans to add 'Last Chance Auditions' videos anywhere on the web. To see it in action, check out idol.ctv.ca. Enabling fans to promote the show they love allows them to let friends in on what's happening with Canadian Idol.
Check out the 'Get and Share' button at the bottom of the widget to easily share 'Last Chance Auditions' anywere on the web. If you live in Facebook, then install the as an application right in your profile 'Last Chance Auditions' Facebook Application
Filemobile peeps give it their best
Tuesday, April 15, 2008 --- CTV Digital has launched Canadian Idol's Last Chance online auditions. This program uses our user-generated white label product and Mediafactory to manage the incoming auditions received by upload or webcam. This is the first time in North America, any eligible contestant with access to a computer can have their chance at a Golden Ticket.
Filemobile's webcam widget is used as part of the Last Chance Auditions, and it is something we are quite proud of. The webcam recorder has been developed using using Wowza Media Sever and Amazon EC2. Wowza gives us the power we need for a fraction of the price of Flash Media Server. Amazon EC2 gives us the scalability that we need when providing services for large media companies. The webcam recorder widget is part of Filemobile's widget publisher.
Press from all over the country have been reporting on this new feature to Canadian Idol.
The Canadian Press wrote the following:
"Canadian Idol" said Monday that wannabe contestants can now get a shot at stardom by submitting an audition video online - and it didn't take long for dream seekers to apply.
Within minutes of the announcement, a few grainy videos appeared on the show's website, http://lastchance.idol.ctv.ca/, most of them featuring off-key amateurs offering up more enthusiasm than talent.
Among the early online offerings Monday were a painful attempt at Bryan Adams' '80s love ballad "Heaven," and a lighthearted take on Nancy Sinatra's "These Boots Were Made For Walkin'," accompanied by animated arm dancing.
Check out CTV's Canadian Idol 'Last Chance auditions' at lastchance.idol.ctv.ca
Check out CTV's press release for 'Last chance auditions' .